What changed at Profound, and what small teams lost
Profound is one of the best-known AI visibility platforms. It asks ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, and other answer engines the questions your buyers ask, then records whether your brand appears, which competitors appear instead, and which pages the answers cite. Until September 2026, a small team could buy it with a card. Starter cost $99 a month for 50 prompts on ChatGPT, and Growth cost $399 a month for three engines.
Between September 14 and September 21, 2026, Profound removed both plans from its pricing page and replaced them with a single free trial (PricingSaaS). As of early November, a brand sees two choices (Profound):
- Trial (free): 50 prompts run daily for 7 days on ChatGPT, Gemini, and Google AI Overviews. You get a recommended prompt set for your industry and can't change it, and the trial keeps no history, exports, or API access.
- Enterprise (custom): up to nine answer engines, a prompt plan you can edit, all-time history, exports, an API, and single sign-on, priced after a demo.
Profound doesn't publish an Enterprise price. Competing vendors estimate typical contracts at somewhere between $1,500 and $5,000 or more a month, figures Profound hasn't confirmed (Eclincher, geotoolbox). Agencies still have a self-serve option, Agency Growth, which geotoolbox lists at $99 a month plus $399 for each client workspace. Brands don't.
The product moved at the same time. Profound announced a $180 million Series D on September 15 and reframed itself around an "AI Marketer" (geotoolbox). Its pricing page now opens with "Meet your AI Marketer." Profound's Agents can draft content for the topics where you're losing ground, write outreach to a source that repeats an inaccurate claim about you, and send a weekly report. They can start on their own when something happens, such as "a 10% drop in Visibility Score" (Profound documentation). They publish to WordPress, Webflow, Contentful, and Sanity, either after a person reviews the draft or directly (Profound Agents FAQ).
So a small team didn't just lose a cheap dashboard. Profound now does the work that turns a visibility report into better answers, and it sells that work to enterprises. The useful question for a small team is which alternative gives you that work at a price you can buy today.
Why the tracker is the easy part to replace
Tracking is now a commodity. Otterly.AI starts at $29 a month, Geoptie at $49, Peec AI at $95, and Semrush's toolkit at $99, all with published prices and no sales call. Any of them will tell you that ChatGPT recommends a competitor when your buyers ask about your category.
None of them changes the answer just by telling you. Carsten Feller, an SEO consultant who ran Otterly's entry plan on his own domain for four weeks, put it plainly: no tool in this category hands you a decision, only an observation you have to turn into a hypothesis and test (feller.systems). Hack'celeration found the same pattern in reviews of Profound itself. The most common complaint was that dashboards show the current state but not what to do next, and some teams pay a consultant to turn the numbers into tasks (Hack'celeration).
The work after the report follows the same steps for every brand:
- Agree on the buyer questions worth tracking.
- Read the pages each answer cites to see why a competitor wins.
- Fix how AI crawlers read your site.
- Write the missing page or improve the one that almost answers the question.
- Get your company into the roundups, reviews, and threads the answers already cite.
- Ask the same questions again and compare.
That loop is what Profound's Agents now automate at Enterprise prices. It's also the clearest way to sort the alternatives. The ten tools below fall into three groups: tools that do the work and publish it, tools that find the fix and prepare it for your team, and trackers that show you where you stand. Within each group, we note what the tool does well and where it hands the work back to you.
Alternatives that do the work and publish it
These tools write content and can push it to your website. They differ in how directly that writing is driven by what AI answers say about you.
1. Kite
- Entry price
- Free; Growth $100/mo with $50 in credits
Kite is an AI marketer. It researches your business, builds a growth strategy, and ships the work that brings you new customers, and AI visibility is one of the jobs it runs from start to finish. You can work with Kite in your browser or in Slack.
It starts with the questions. Kite uses what it already knows about your products, positioning, customers, and competitors to propose the buyer questions worth tracking, and it sends you the list to change or approve. You can add exact prompts of your own. Once you agree, that list becomes the fixed set Kite checks on every run (Kite). Kite runs the questions through ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, and Claude. For every answer, it records whether you're mentioned, which competitors appear, and which pages are cited, then measures your rank, visibility, and share of voice against those competitors. For Google, it flags which of your keywords show an AI Overview and checks whether the overview cites you or a competitor.
Measurement is where most trackers stop, and it's where Kite's work begins:
- It opens the pages each answer cites and checks which companies they mention, what kind of page they are, and how directly they answer the question. It adds search rankings, backlinks, and domain authority to explain why a competitor keeps winning.
- It scans your public website with 24 checks across crawl access, content, structured data, AI guidance such as
llms.txt, and brand presence. It scores the site out of 100 and ranks the fixes by how many points each would recover. - It decides whether to improve an existing page or create a new one, such as a category page, a direct comparison, or a clearer answer on a page that already ranks. It writes the page in your brand voice.
- It publishes approved work to a site it builds and hosts for you, or through Webflow, WordPress, Contentful, Sanity, Storyblok, or a GitHub repository.
- When a roundup or review page keeps getting cited without mentioning you, it finds the person responsible for that page and drafts the outreach for your team to send.
Then Kite measures again with the same questions. Each page it publishes stays tied to the prompts it was written for, so the comparison can show which change moved which answers. Suppose Kite added a pricing comparison to your product page because three tracked questions about cost kept citing a competitor's page. If those three questions now cite your page while the rest of the set stays the same, that's good evidence the change worked. If answers moved everywhere at once, a competitor's launch or an update to the answer engine is the likelier cause. You can ask Kite to repeat the assessment on a schedule, so you keep seeing how your visibility moves.
Kite proposes work by default. You approve it with the Approve or Publish button in the conversation, or by replying, and you can give Kite more autonomy once you trust what it ships. One plan covers your whole team, with no cap on the number of people. There's a free plan with access to the complete product, a Growth plan at $100 a month that includes $50 in AI credits, and custom pricing for Business (Kite pricing). Kite bills by usage rather than by prompt count, so the cost of tracking depends on how many questions you run and how often. Its tracking covers four engines, and Google's AI answers are covered through the AI Overview check rather than as a separately tracked engine.
If you want a look before you sign up, try Kite's free AI visibility checker. It asks ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, and Claude the questions your customers ask, and in about 45 seconds it shows whether they recommend your business and who they recommend instead. It's free and doesn't need an account.
Kite is the strongest fit when you want one marketer that owns the whole loop: choosing the questions, finding the cause, shipping the fix, and proving whether it worked. The AI answer visibility use case walks through each step, and the Kite vs Profound comparison covers the two side by side.
2. Frase
- Entry price
- $39/mo yearly, $49 monthly
Frase is an SEO and content platform with an agent that writes and publishes. Frase Agent reads the pages already ranking, drafts in your brand voice, and rewrites from a line of feedback (Frase). It publishes to WordPress, Webflow, Sanity, or Wix, or hosts the page on FraseCMS, which is free up to 100,000 page views a month. You can let the agent publish on its own for a content type, and Content Guard watches your pages' Google rankings and clicks each week, drafts a fix when one slips, and republishes it once you approve (Frase pricing).
Frase is the cheapest tool here that writes and ships content: Starter costs $39 a month billed yearly, or $49 month to month, for one site, 10 articles, and 50 audit pages a month. There's a 7-day trial with no card.
The limit is how the two halves connect. Frase's AI Visibility feature tracks 20 prompts on ChatGPT and Google AI on Starter, adding Perplexity on Professional ($103 a month yearly) and Claude and Gemini on Scale. Frase says AI Visibility "does not auto-fix" and "never touches your content." The fixing runs on Google rank and traffic decay, not on what AI answers say. Frase fits a team whose main goal is Google rankings and who will connect the AI-answer findings to the writing themselves.
3. AthenaHQ
- Entry price
- Free tier; Starter $295/mo
AthenaHQ tracks a wide engine list and can draft and deliver page changes. Its Content workspace lets you write new drafts, optimize existing pages, or "snipe" a competitor's highly cited page. You approve a brief, Athena generates the full article, and you can publish or schedule it to a connected CMS (AthenaHQ documentation). When its Site Health audit finds a problem, "Fix with Athena" drafts the change. You approve or reject each edit, apply it to your CMS, and Athena checks the live page about 24 hours later to confirm the change went through (AthenaHQ documentation).
Pricing is by credit, where one credit buys one AI response. A free Essential tier includes 300 credits across ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, Gemini, and Copilot. Starter costs $295 a month for 3,600 credits, covers ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overviews, AI Mode, Gemini, Claude, Copilot, and Grok, and is labelled for "Self-Guided SMBs" (AthenaHQ).
Two limits matter for a small team. Credits thin out fast across many engines: Searchmaxxed works out that 3,600 credits spread over seven engines cover about 17 prompts a day (Searchmaxxed). And direct delivery works only with CMSs that support it, such as Sanity and Contentful; other sites need an export, and structured data changes are always installed by hand. The advanced content agent, multiple countries, and Athena's recommendation engine sit on Enterprise.
4. Writesonic
- Entry price
- $79/mo billed annually
Writesonic pairs an AI visibility tracker with an AI article writer and site audits. Starter costs $79 a month billed annually and tracks 50 prompts daily on ChatGPT, Gemini, and Google AI Overviews, with 15 AI articles and 10 site audits a month (Writesonic). Reviewer Marc Andrews reports the month-to-month price as $99 (marcandrews.com).
The piece that ties fixes to AI answers is the Action Center. It groups gaps into new content, page refreshes, outreach to sites that cite competitors, and technical fixes, ranks them, and pushes page refreshes to your CMS in one click (Writesonic). On the pricing page, the full Action Center is Enterprise only. Growth, at $399 a month billed annually, gets a trial of 5 on-page and 5 off-page actions a month, and Starter and Basic get none. The three self-serve plans also leave Perplexity, Claude, and Copilot to Enterprise.
Andrews' test of Writesonic's free report shows why the setup step matters. Writesonic read his software review site as a video production and Webflow agency, wrote 30 tracking prompts about services he doesn't offer, and scored him second of six on share of voice against the wrong competitors. His advice applies to any tool: check the country, topics, prompts, and competitors before you trust a number. Writesonic fits a team that wants articles and tracking in one subscription and will act on the gaps itself until it can afford the Action Center.
Alternatives that find the fix and prepare it for your team
These tools go past the dashboard. They rank what to fix, draft briefs or suggested edits, and point you at the sources worth pursuing. Your team still writes the final page and publishes it.
5. Peec AI
- Entry price
- $95/mo
Peec AI is a tracker that recently learned to prepare the work. Its October 2026 release redesigned its recommended actions and added Peec Agent (Peec AI). Actions now cover technical fixes such as blocked crawlers and broken schema, suggested edits shown beside your existing page, content briefs for topics where competitors keep getting cited, off-page sources with the people behind them, and inaccurate claims traced to the pages that caused them. Peec says its first version of actions "deliberately stopped short of generating content for you." The new version still leaves the publishing decision with you: "You decide which changes to publish."
Peec Agent answers questions about your data, helps expand your tracked prompts, and works through more than 25 connected tools to create a ticket, prepare a brief, or draft outreach. Any change it wants to make waits for your approval unless you turn on automatic approval (Peec AI documentation). Starter costs $95 a month for 50 prompts tracked daily on three models you choose from ChatGPT, AI Mode, AI Overviews, Copilot, Gemini, and Naver AI, with unlimited users and 500 agent credits a month (Peec AI). Perplexity is an add-on at $30 a month on Starter, and Claude sits on Enterprise.
Peec's strength is research and planning. Mindy Faieta at Stateshift moved her team from Otterly to Peec "primarily because of the workflow for content planning" (Stateshift). It fits a team with a writer who wants clear, evidenced briefs and is happy to ship the pages themselves.
6. Scrunch
- Entry price
- $250/mo
Scrunch is the closest thing to Profound's analysis at a published price. Core costs $250 a month for 125 prompts, 5,000 responses, five site audits, AI bot traffic data, and five user licenses, tracked on ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, and Copilot, with a 7-day trial (Scrunch). It shows which crawlers reach your pages, which sources shape the answers, and what to fix.
The fixing is light on Core. The plan includes one page optimization a month and "basic" content generation, and it covers one country, one language, and one buyer persona. Scrunch's bigger delivery product, the Agent Experience Platform, serves an AI-optimized version of your pages to AI crawlers at the CDN layer. It's an Enterprise item, and Scrunch says it suits sites with hundreds or thousands of pages (Scrunch help center). Scrunch fits a team selling in one market that wants a strong diagnosis and will do most of the content work in-house.
7. AIclicks
- Entry price
- $59/mo
AIclicks is a low-cost tracker with a content allowance. Starter costs $59 a month for 30 prompts on three engines you choose, five AI-optimized articles a month, a CMS integration, and its agent, Clicky (AIclicks). Its Recommendations tab ranks three kinds of action by expected impact: create AI-optimized content, get mentioned on sources AI engines already trust, and join conversations on platforms like Reddit (AIclicks). It collects answers through each engine's user interface rather than its API, and AIclicks says it can monitor more than ten engines.
AIclicks doesn't say what Clicky does on its own or who approves an article before it publishes, so test that during the trial. The trial lasts three days and needs a card. AIclicks fits a team that wants a few drafts a month alongside a ranked to-do list.
8. Geoptie
- Entry price
- $49/mo
Geoptie is an affordable tracker with built-in drafting. Starter costs $49 a month for 15 prompts and two brands, tracked daily on any four of seven engines: ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, Perplexity, Copilot, Google AI Overviews, and AI Mode (Geoptie). Every plan includes unlimited audit reports and content generation with no credits, and plans run month to month.
Each gap becomes a ranked action, such as joining a Reddit thread, adding a comparison table to a page, or getting listed in a roundup. Geoptie writes drafts "built on the sources AI already trusts" and scores them before you publish. Its MCP server lets you ask a coding agent like Claude Code to "Write an article for our top recommendation." Geoptie doesn't say it publishes to your site, so plan on shipping the drafts yourself. There's no free trial, only a demo and free tools. It fits a technical founder who wants cheap tracking on the engines they choose and is comfortable finishing drafts with their own tools.
Trackers that show you where you stand
These tools measure well and leave the work to you. They suit a team that already has someone to act on the findings, or one that wants proof the channel matters before spending more.
9. Otterly.AI
- Entry price
- $29/mo
Otterly.AI is the cheapest published plan that tracks four engines from day one. Lite costs $29 a month for 15 prompts checked daily on ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity, and Copilot, with unlimited team members (Otterly.AI). Gemini and AI Mode cost $9 a month each on Lite, and Claude costs $29. Lite includes three recommendations a week and 1,000 GEO page audits a month.
Feller called the Lite plan a fair deal, with prices shown openly rather than behind a contact form, and a pragmatic way in, but not a long-term solution for a company with several brands (feller.systems). There's no tier between 15 and 100 prompts, so prompt sixteen moves you to Standard at $189. He set the recommendations aside because he couldn't trace how they were derived. Faieta's team found Otterly "helpful for monitoring," but it couldn't help them explore which topics to pursue (Stateshift). Otterly fits a solo marketer who wants to prove AI answers matter before asking for a bigger budget.
10. Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit
- Entry price
- $99/mo
Semrush's AI Visibility Toolkit makes sense when your SEO already runs in Semrush. It costs $99 a month for one domain, 25 tracked prompts, prompt research, brand performance reports with AI-generated recommendations, and an AI search site audit for up to 100 pages (Semrush). Fifty more prompts cost $60 a month, and each extra user costs $99. There's no free trial.
The toolkit's advantage is context: you see AI answers on the same screen as your keyword rankings. Its limit is a narrow tracked set and no help doing the work. Ahrefs offers a similar add-on, Brand Radar, for teams that research in Ahrefs.
How the 10 alternatives compare
The table shows the main split: who does the work after a gap is found, and what you get on the cheapest plan you can buy without a sales call.
|
Tool |
Who does the work after a gap is found |
Engines on the entry plan |
Entry price |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Kite |
Kite diagnoses, writes, publishes on your approval, and measures again |
ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude, plus Google AI Overview checks |
Free; Growth $100/mo with $50 in credits |
|
Frase |
The agent writes and can publish, driven by Google decay rather than AI answers |
ChatGPT and Google AI (20 prompts) |
$39/mo yearly, $49 monthly |
|
AthenaHQ |
Athena drafts articles and fixes; you approve and deliver to your CMS |
At least eight, including Claude and Grok |
Free tier; Starter $295/mo |
|
Writesonic |
Writes articles; the AI-answer fix list is Enterprise, with a trial on Growth |
ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Overviews |
$79/mo billed annually |
|
Peec AI |
Ranks actions and drafts briefs and edits; your team publishes |
Three of six (Perplexity is a $30 add-on; Claude is Enterprise) |
$95/mo |
|
Scrunch |
Diagnoses and audits; one page optimization a month |
ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Overviews, Copilot |
$250/mo |
|
AIclicks |
Ranks actions and writes five articles a month |
Three of your choice |
$59/mo |
|
Geoptie |
Ranks actions and writes drafts; your team publishes |
Four of seven, your choice |
$49/mo |
|
Otterly.AI |
Your team, with three recommendations a week |
ChatGPT, AI Overviews, Perplexity, Copilot |
$29/mo |
|
Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit |
Your team, with recommendations inside Semrush |
Platforms including ChatGPT and Google AI Mode |
$99/mo |
|
Profound, for reference |
Agents write and publish, on Enterprise |
Trial: ChatGPT, Gemini, AI Overviews |
Free 7-day trial; Enterprise by quote |
Prices and plan details come from each vendor's pages as of early November 2026. Several vendors in this category have changed prices in the last two months, so confirm them on the day you buy.
How to choose a Profound alternative
Start with one question: who on your team will do the work once the report shows a gap? If nobody has a few hours a week to write pages and pitch sources, a tracker will mostly confirm what you already suspect. Searchmaxxed puts it bluntly: "Without an owner, a tracker is an expensive screenshot" (Searchmaxxed).
- If you want the work handled, choose from the first group. Kite runs the whole loop from AI answers to published pages and back. Frase and Writesonic also write and publish content, but Frase's writing runs on Google decay rather than AI answers, and Writesonic ties its fixes to AI answers only on its higher plans. AthenaHQ sits between them, with a wide engine list and a credit budget to manage.
- If you have a writer, a tool from the second group gives them evidence-backed briefs and a ranked list. Peec AI is the strongest planner there, and Scrunch is the strongest diagnosis.
- If you only need proof the channel matters, Otterly.AI is the cheapest place to start, and Semrush is the easiest if you already pay for it.
Then check three things before you pay:
- Approve the questions yourself. The prompt list decides every number downstream. Profound's trial won't let you edit its prompts. Writesonic built Andrews' prompts for a business he doesn't run. Feller found two prompts from the same suggestion tool that differed by one verb and scored 46 percent and 2 percent. Pick a tool that lets you review and change the list, and start from questions your buyers actually ask on sales calls.
- Match the engines to your buyers. Many entry plans leave out Perplexity or Claude. If your buyers use them, check the exact plan before you look at the headline price.
- Measure with the same questions over time. AI answers vary from run to run. SparkToro found a less than 1-in-100 chance that ChatGPT or Google's AI in Search would return the same list of brands twice for the same prompt, although in tight categories the leading brands still appeared in most answers (Search Engine Journal). Judge a change by your share of answers across a fixed set of questions before and after, not by one day's chart.
Common questions
Is there a free Profound alternative?
Several tools let you start without paying. Kite's free plan includes access to the complete product with no recurring subscription, and its free AI visibility checker needs no account at all. AthenaHQ's Essential tier is free with 300 credits. Frase gives a 7-day trial with no card, and Scrunch and Otterly.AI offer free trials too. Profound's own trial is free for seven days, but it runs a prompt set you can't edit and keeps no history afterward.
Should a small team choose Profound or Peec AI?
For most small teams, Peec AI is the one you can actually buy. It publishes its prices, starts at $95 a month, and gives every plan unlimited users, recommended actions, and an agent. Profound covers more engines and its Agents can write and publish content, but a brand reaches all of that only through an Enterprise quote. Neither one publishes new pages to your site on a plan a brand can buy without a sales call, so if you want the writing and publishing done for you, look at the first group above.
When is Profound still worth it?
Profound still makes sense for larger companies that need its Enterprise features on one contract. That means single sign-on and SOC 2 compliance, up to nine answer engines, Prompt Volumes data on what people ask AI engines, ChatGPT Shopping tracking, an API, and a dedicated specialist (Profound). If you need all of that and have someone to act on the findings, a cheaper tracker will cost more in workarounds than it saves.
Can I bring my Profound data to a new tool?
You can bring your prompt list but not your history. Profound lets paid accounts export prompts and topics, but not past scores, mentions, and citations, and no alternative imports Profound history (Hack'celeration). The trial has no exports at all. Copy your prompts word for word, run the new tool for a few weeks to build a fresh baseline, and compare trends from there.
Sources
- Meet your AI Marketer (Profound pricing), Profound
- About Agents, Profound documentation
- Agents FAQ, Profound documentation
- Profound: Paid self-serve tiers removed (week 39 change record), PricingSaaS
- Profound Pricing: How Much Does Profound Cost Today?, geotoolbox
- Profound Alternatives: 8 AI Visibility Tools After Profound's Pricing Change, Eclincher
- Profound alternatives: where to go and how to keep your tracking, Hack'celeration
- Profound Alternatives 2026: 9 Tools Compared, Searchmaxxed
- Otterly.ai Lite im Praxistest, Carsten Feller, feller.systems
- AI Recommendations Change With Nearly Every Query: SparkToro, Search Engine Journal
- Frase: Rank on Google. Get cited by AI., Frase
- Frase Pricing, Frase
- AthenaHQ Plans & Pricing, AthenaHQ
- Content, AthenaHQ documentation
- Page edits board, AthenaHQ documentation
- Plans & Pricing, Writesonic
- AI Visibility Action Center, Writesonic
- Writesonic AI Search Report tested (2026), Marc Andrews
- Turn opportunities into impact with Peec Agent and actions, Peec AI
- Agent, Peec AI documentation
- Pricing for Brands, Peec AI
- Peec AI Review: What We Learned After 3 Months of Testing, Stateshift
- Pricing that scales with you, Scrunch
- Agent Experience Platform (AXP), Scrunch help center
- Win AI Search With The Right Plan, AIclicks
- AIclicks: Actions to Win AI Search, AIclicks
- Geoptie: Turn AI search into traffic, Geoptie
- OtterlyAI pricing, OtterlyAI
- AI Visibility Toolkit, Semrush Knowledge Base